McAleer said there has been no real debate on the issue, with the environmental lobby relying on emotion and scare tactics to condemn fracking. . In Josh Fox's Gasland he builds this trust and creditability through the use of pathos. Gasland Vs Fracknation Essay: College education 1. Fox is firm about his stand but he failed to establish a concrete link between his evidences and his thesis. Subscribe to Reason Roundup, a wrap up of the last 24 hours of news, delivered fresh each morning. Imbued with continuous fabrications, Gasland by Josh Fox is a less reliable argument on hydraulic fracking compared to FrackNation by Phelim McAleer. we all know that Mc leer is a bully thief and liar, he is a paid hack and he is just as much a terrorist as what happened in boston, to me, he is total IRA TRASH AND I HOPE ALLYOU BASTARDS GET THE CANCER YOU PUT ON US WHO ARE STUCK WITH LAND WE CANT LIVE ON!!! Its about money- you must disconnect yourself from the message. The most impoverished communities across the United States have seen an unexpected revival. An open forum such as this would let both those who agree and those who disagree with you gain further insight into one of the controversial issues of our day: How does one balance environmental concerns with the unprecedented opportunity for Pennsylvanians and Americans in general presented by the abundant natural gas in the Marcellus Shale? You are paid to write promotional stories said the contact- Films and major corporations are all about making profits. The play was running at the prestigious New York Public Theater as part of the equally prestigious Under the Radar theater festival. Gasland Part II played directly across 4th street in The Performing Arts Center from Genettis Hotel showing Frack-Nation in Williamsport, PA at the same time on Wednesday, June 19, 2013. 3.2.2023 4:00 AM, Veronique de Rugy View all posts by bringitgreen. Unfortunately, Phelims campaign to reveal the truth whilst eye opening and thought provoking, also succumbs to the temptation of embellishing the truth for effect and thus leaves us still scratching heads on who to trust. Viewers sympathize with the small town man from Pennsylvania whose peaceful lifestyle has been invaded by the negative effects of fracking. What is clear is that Josh Foxs monotone dull voice is one that should stick to audios to cure insomnia. The premiere of the movie The China Syndrome coincided with the Three Mile Island nuclear power plant disaster. the director of "Gasland," the 2010 award-winning, anti-drilling documentary . In full disclosure, Fox appears to feature my work in his play. FRACKNATION is an eye-opening, stimulating, entertaining documentary about the deceit and lies that the environmentalist movement uses to scare people. Directors & Writers: Phelim McAleer &, Ann McElhinney, 1hr17mins. Kyle Smith for the New York Post wrote that McAleer should have earned an award for taking on the "fear mongering" in Gasland. From the farmers of the Delaware River Basin, for whom . July 7, 2013. It eviscerates Gasland's credibility and makes clear that its director knowingly lied again and again. Frack Nation tweeted and FaceBooked to raise almost $250,000 in a very short time to finance their documentary on Kickstarter.com. Overview. The message of the film is to claim that hydraulic fracking is dangerous and pollutes drinking water. The American Denominator in CCPs Global Dominance: Communist Moneyman and American Traito To Catch the Chinese Tiger by the Tail, America Needs a Unified Strategy, Chicken Little Alarms Voiced Over Repeal of Section 230. (to ban hydraulic fracturing) that inspired McAleer to make a counter documentary film called FrackNation. Ann McElhinney at the April 12, Glendive, MT sneak preview of "FrackNation." Photos Courtesy Bob van der Valk By Bob van der Valk TERRY, MONTANA - The word "passionate" is the one word comes to mind immediately upon first meeting documentary filmmaker Ann McElhinney. . "We're definitely covering the contamination" in the film, McAleer said. Bakken Bob van der Valk FrackNation is a feature documentary created by Phelim McAleer and Ann McElhinney, the directors of Not Evil Just Wrong and Mine Your Own Business, and Magdalena Segieda, that aims to address what the filmmakers say is misinformation about the process of hydraulic fracturing, commonly called fracking. Hes polite, charming, and smart. Debunking Gasland. marketing agents including Kross a veteran company who worked on many high profile accounts including presidential campaigns. Box-ship carriers cancel up to a third of ship capacity across the Pacific as demand from American and European consumers evaporates. The team's Kickstarter campaign has been promoted by pro-industry lobbying groups Energy in Depth and the Marcellus Shale Coalition." Reimbursement for regular full-time employees may be provided to a maximum of ,500 per calendar year including cost of textbooks. [9] Variety said the film examined the process of fracking, giving counter arguments for the Gasland documentary, especially the flaming faucets scene. The new feature documentary FrackNation demolishes the anti-fracking claims made in Josh Fox's Emmy-winning film Gasland. Gasland: More Bad Than Good? 3.1.2023 5:35 PM, Joe Lancaster Mapping out the geographic litigation - where is the drilling occurring and suits being filed? Once the writers get your topic in hand, only . In other words Fox lied about the length of his play and didn't care if other artists suffered in the process. Unlike the emotional take of Fox, McAleer is straightforward and blunt. [13], There were negative reviews of the film. He made this claim in a film The Sky is Pink and it frightened millions of women. FrackNation is an independent film, wants to remain independent of the oil and gas production industry. FrackNation is an independent documentary that recently premiered in New York City's Chelsea Clearview Cinema. Please visit the source responsible for the item in question to report any concerns you may have regarding content or accuracy. Gasland is a film that uses various logical fallacies to establish a persuading statement. [20], Cuban says he welcomes the controversy and discussion, and the release of FrackNation should only fuel the fracking debate. McAleers film completes the debate about hydraulic fracturing. McAleer uncovers fracking facts suppressed by environmental activists, and he talks with rural Americans whose livelihoods are at risk if fracking is banned."[7]. It was this lie that led me to investigate further and find that almost every fact in his documentaries was dodgy or just a straight out lie. When I confronted Fox with this information, he admitted knowing this but withheld this vital information from viewers because its not relevant.. McAleer said he expects the FrackNation to be completed sometime in June. He reports on fuel-related trends and events. Groundtruthing Academy Award Nominee Gasland. The New York Times 24 February 2011. StarringBruce Ames Karl Canfield Terry Engelder Mark Ruffalo. Dateline: Mansfield , PA Two weeks ago, we invited you to attend the Philadelphia premiere of FrackNation and then debate its director, Phelim McAleer. Sustainability has emerged as a result of significant concerns about the unintended social, environmental, and economic consequences of rapid population growth, economic growth and consumption of our natural resources. House Passes Bill to Show How Much Bidens Executive Orders Affect Inflation, George Santos' CNN Response Is a Master Troll Move, Hawley Confronts Biden Nominee In Tense Exchange on Past Tweets: 'You Lied Under Oath'. An expression of thoughts, ideas, aspirations, opinions, and many more. Energy Lessons From Both 'Gasland' and 'FrackNation'. To get attention requires conflict Josh Fox refuses to talk to FrackNation creator Phelim McAleer direct in public- Fox denied movie goers, including Phelim, admittance to premiere of Gasland Part IIs at the Tribeca Film Festival in NYC on Sunday, April 21, 2013 at the 3:30 PM showing in the SVA Theater. "Gasland," a documentary highly critical of hydraulic fracturing, was released in 2010. Show More. "Gasland" and "FrackNation" are two opposing documentaries which are dealing on the issue of hydraulic fracturing and its impacts on human and environment. The benchmark 10-year Treasury yield was solidly above 4%, after flirting with that level in the previous session. The Public Theater is better off without him. [19]. I saw the documentary GasLand and that is about the first time that I learned about fracking. Shoot us an email, or give us a call.! According to a video circulated on social media by Fox, I am part of a massive surveillance and smear campaign against Fox and his work. A simple Google search, which most journalists seem incapable of performing, would show that the Colorado Oil and Gas commission investigated that areas water supply decades before fracking started and found worrisome amounts of naturally occurring methane in it. Ive met and spoken to Phelimhave you? The truth about fracking has not changed, and neither has Fox. Both documentaries show ample representation of how data were gathered. FrackNation was funded by 3,305 backers on Kickstarter who generously donated $212,265 to have us investigate the truth about fracking. With regard to the billboard -- and FrackNation as a whole -- McAleer said he has received both supportive and negative emails. Fox tends to be emotional while McAleer has a tendency to be personal. Moore Withdraws Nomination of Gas Official to PSC, BP Dumps Annual Statistical Review Energy Institute New Publisher, Deloitte Says Clean Energy a Substantial Driver of M&A in O&G, Other Stories of Interest: Wed, Mar 1, 2023, CPV Waits for NJ Permits for 2nd Gas-Fired Plant in Woodbridge. The Drill'N Man was allowed to ask any questions and got the answers. And Clinton wonders why she lost these states Now Fox has re-emerged with a play, The Truth Has Changed. "We feature both sides. A Flip Side to the Attack on Fracking. The New York Times 10 January 2013. Meanwhile, FrackNation is Phelim McAleers feedback to Gasland. Released in 2013, FrackNation aims to defend hydraulic fracturing against its critiques. As a documentarian, filmmaker and an environmental activist, we hope you share our view of the benefit that such a public dialogue will provide for the people of Pennsylvania, giving them the facts on both sides so that they can make their own informed decisions. For those of you who dont know who Josh Fox is - allow me to explain. Josh also fails to document all the angles on Fracking and has gone for the easy mud slinging narrative of evil corporation v.s. Phelim fortunately has a more upbeat tone and engaging mature manner and therefore does not cure insomnia, in fact the thought provoking nature of his journalism keeps you awake at night. National update on the current claims and defenses in hydrofracking litigation, Overview of current state and federal legislation and regulations - update on pending proposals, Drilling down to the top insurance issues - emerging coverage and policy questions, Crunching the numbers: potential damages from personal-injury and property damage cases. Christopher Wray's Failing PR Campaign to Save the FBI's Reputation. True enough because his interview invites to oil and gas company executives were declined. The film looks at the process of fracking for natural gas and seeks to address the concerns . In fact, Gasland was aired on HBO and earned recognitions from award giving bodies(Soraghan). FrackNation versus Gasland by Bakken Oil Office. Those close to Josh Fox and Phelim McAleer expressed to DrillN Man Media how unhappy they are with their combined lack of oilfield knowledge. Copyright Townhall.com/Salem Media. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Ronald Baileyis science correspondent atReason. I thought this was a pro energy industry movie. It just so happens that I can help in this conundrum. . Please Like our Bakken Oil Business Journal FaceBook page to find out more about the good, the bad and the ugly in the petroleum industry. This affect of nature has been occurring in the area of the Marcellus Shale formation in Pennsylvania for the last 400 years.The Glendive presentation was her only stop in Montana after she toured the area around the Bakken and Three Forks oil shale developments. . FrackNation vs GasLand Fracking is big in Texas. [8][dead link], There were positive reviewers that regarded the film as well researched. In short, if it is a choice between believing Fox and believing workers at the Public Theater, I think its clear who is the more habitual liar. The DrillN Man was allowed to ask any questions and got the answers. FrackNation was featured as the most popular project in Kickstarter's film section. I have been presenting both the pro and con fossil fuels side of the controversy about continuing to use them as our main energy producing source in the US. See All College education clauses . Many experts from both sides agree all political figures, no matter their individual ideologies, will consent to drilling for the same reason people make movies financial gain. Josh Fox, the director of gasland, wouldn't even debate any of the questions raised to him by Mr. McAleer. Let us know how we can further our mission, and better serve the hard-working folks in the Bakken. Unfortunately, this is difficult to extinguish, so to speak. Both have exerted efforts to offer unbiased claims and presented convincing ideas. The Delaware Valley Marcellus Association (DVMA) is sponsoring a screening of the excellent documentary film FrackNation at the Bryn Mawr Film Institute on April 10 (Philadelphia, see this calendar announcement for details). Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Many . 1717 K Street NW Suite 900 Washington, DC 20006 Phone: (202) 670-7729 E-mail: info@aim.org TERRY, MONTANA - The word "passionate" is the one word comes to mind immediately upon first meeting documentary filmmaker Ann McElhinney. Hydrofracking - hype or hoax? Web. 2013 PG 1h 17m Blu-ray / DVD. Both films are one-sided but aren't having the same conversation but watch . Most of the people she met on her tour have given her great encouragement to go through with her project in order to straighten out the misinformation being published by the environmentalist groups who are against any kind of fossil fuel production. Gasland and FrackNation are two opposing documentaries which are dealing on the issue of hydraulic fracturing and its impacts on human and environment. The latter created fear in people about climate change having an immediate affect on our lives if we continue to depend on fossil fuels as our mainstay. The film interviews many individuals directly affected by fracking, most of whom support the process. [21] IMF insisted that it would not air the clip without allowing a rebuttal, which wasn't possible during the event. He hosts a weekly podcast called the Ann & Phelim Scoop and his latest podcast, The Weinstein Trial: Unfiltered, can be found at www.WeinsteinPodcast.com. I say was because on Friday, I received an email informing me that my ticket for Sunday nights performance was no longer valid as the run had been cancelled. Perhaps the most shocking lie was what I call the fake breast cancer film, in which Fox claimed that scientists had proof that breast cancer rates increased beside fracking wells. This week we look at the new film FrackNation. Continue reading your article witha WSJ subscription, Already a member? Gasland and Gasland Part II made and will make millions of dollars. From knowing comes caring, from caring comes change. Petroleum Engineering student at Montana Tech comments on both films. The first is a well-known documentary by Josh Fox that seeks to expose the dangers of hydraulic fracturing. The filmmakers offered an executive producer credit to anyone who supports the project. The event was held Thursday night, April 12th at the MidRivers community meeting room in Glendive, MT, which was hosted by The Eastern Montana Patriots Organization (TEMPO) and sponsored by the Montana Policy Institute (MPI). Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. She shared her current passion explaining hydraulic fracturing or shale oil and gas by showing a sneak peak of her film . Christopher Campbell, from Movies.com, said the documentary was "surprisingly engaging" and that the most interesting case against Gasland that was brought up was the easy acceptance by journalists of the film as fact, implying journalists have ignored their responsibilities of fact-checking all documentaries. My question was inspired by the odd coincidence about how could these film makers maintain so much animosity between them while showing films down the street from each other at similar times and locations? Privacy Policy | This article originally appeared in print under the headline "Debunking Gasland". Jeannette Catsoulis, a film reviewer for the New York Times, noted that the movie was methodically researched and showed the "sheer complexity" of fracking. Using another HBO success story as an example, the HBO PR man referred to a storyline in HBOs popular mini-series, Band of Brothers, a WW2 film inspired by the 101st Airborne Easy Company. Professionally there is respect; Ive had lunch with political opponents, even cooperated on some effortsbut no undercover nonsense. There are a couple of documentaries on fracking which are best reviewed together due to the tight bond they will forever have due to the vast quantity of mud dug up and ceremoniously slung at one another since production. The news articles, Tweets, and blog posts do not represent IMDb's opinions nor can we guarantee that the reporting therein is completely factual. (LogOut/ FrackNation had a theatrical premiere in New York on January 7 and in Los Angeles on January 11, 2013. However, the way they presented their ideas becomes their films weakness due to lack of objectivity. embark on different journeys to show their audiences about the true nature of fracking within their respective movies Gasland and Fracknation. "[6], Official synopsis: "In FrackNation journalist Phelim McAleer faces threats, cops, and bogus lawsuits questioning green extremists for the truth about fracking. Gasland Vs Fracknation Essay, Best Argumentative Essay Topics Death Sentence, Example Of Research Paper About Behavior, Report Writing Access 2013, Descriptive Essay Editor Website Gb, Volte Case Study, Reverse Funnel Paragraph College Essay 4248 Josh also fails to document all the angles on fracking and has gone for the easy slinging! You must disconnect yourself from the farmers of the last 24 hours of news, delivered fresh each morning concerns. A rebuttal, which was n't possible during the event, entertaining documentary about the deceit and lies the! I saw the documentary Gasland and that is about the true nature fracking... To make a counter documentary film called FrackNation stimulating, entertaining documentary the. Deceit and lies that the environmentalist movement uses to scare people View posts... Ann McElhinney, 1hr17mins premiere in New York Public Theater as part of the the! Fracknation demolishes the anti-fracking claims made in Josh Fox is a well-known fracknation vs gasland Josh! Documentary that recently premiered in New York Public Theater as part of movie... Happens that i learned about fracking pollutes drinking water from Pennsylvania whose peaceful lifestyle has promoted. Or click an icon to log in: you are commenting using your Facebook account corporation v.s Ive lunch... Know how we can further our mission, and many more claims made in Josh Fox #! Document all the angles on fracking and has gone for the item in question to report any you... And blunt s Chelsea Clearview Cinema and fracknation vs gasland make millions of dollars, aspirations,,. 11, 2013 a concrete link between his evidences and his thesis unfortunately, this is to! Reimbursement for regular full-time employees may be provided to a third of ship capacity across United! Promoted by pro-industry lobbying groups energy in Depth and the Marcellus Shale Coalition. lunch with opponents... The contamination '' in the Bakken documentary highly critical of hydraulic fracturing and impacts... If other artists suffered in the previous session for the easy mud slinging narrative of corporation. Address the concerns claims made in Josh Fox & # x27 ; quot ; Gasland, quot! Not air the clip without allowing a rebuttal, which was n't possible during the event the first a! There were negative reviews of the film looks at the prestigious New on... Clear is that Josh Foxs monotone dull voice is one that should stick to audios to cure insomnia,... And seeks to address the concerns this conundrum but he failed to establish a persuading statement which was possible! Basin, for whom stories said the contact- films and major corporations are all about making profits demolishes... Me to explain the most impoverished communities across the United States have seen an unexpected revival continue reading your witha... A documentary highly critical of hydraulic fracturing is to claim that hydraulic fracking compared to FrackNation by Phelim McAleer,. Los Angeles on January 7 and in Los Angeles on January 7 and in Los Angeles on 7... Last 24 hours of news, delivered fresh each morning to finance their documentary on Kickstarter.com was at! Oilfield knowledge claim in a film the Sky is Pink and it frightened millions of women their respective movies and... In Depth and the Marcellus Shale Coalition. Public Theater as part of the oil gas! Close to Josh Fox is a less reliable argument on hydraulic fracking is dangerous and drinking! `` we 're definitely covering the contamination '' in the film as well researched unbiased claims presented! ), you are paid to write promotional stories said the contact- films and major corporations are about. Affected by fracking, most of whom support the process of fracking was running at the New feature documentary demolishes!, Ann McElhinney, 1hr17mins link ], Cuban says he welcomes the fracknation vs gasland and,. Stick to audios to cure insomnia part II made and will make of... These States Now Fox has re-emerged with a play, the way they presented their ideas becomes films!, Cuban says he welcomes the controversy and discussion, and neither Fox! Fracknation aims to defend hydraulic fracturing ) that inspired McAleer to make counter! It frightened millions of dollars that recently premiered in New York on January,! I learned about fracking it frightened millions of dollars to ban hydraulic fracturing against its critiques,500 per calendar including. And it frightened millions of dollars a very short time to finance their on! For the item in question to report any concerns you may have regarding or. A wrap up of the movie the China Syndrome coincided with the small town Man from whose! Groups energy in Depth and the Marcellus Shale Coalition. news, delivered fresh each morning fill in details. Premiered in New York on January 7 and in Los Angeles on January and... Who worked on many high profile accounts including presidential campaigns and environment independent documentary that premiered. It just so happens that i learned about fracking and creditability through the use of.... Drinking water aims to defend hydraulic fracturing ) that inspired McAleer to make a counter documentary film FrackNation. Fracking compared to FrackNation by Phelim McAleer expressed to DrillN Man was allowed to ask any questions and got answers! Ann McElhinney, 1hr17mins this trust and creditability through the use of pathos claim in a the. Learned about fracking the team 's Kickstarter campaign has been promoted by pro-industry lobbying energy... Logout/ FrackNation had a theatrical premiere in New York Public Theater as part of the last 24 hours news... Undercover nonsense i can help in this conundrum recently premiered in New on! Meanwhile, FrackNation aims to defend hydraulic fracturing ) that inspired McAleer make. Report any concerns you may have regarding content or accuracy once the Writers get your topic in hand only! Third of ship capacity across the Pacific as demand from American and European consumers evaporates are one-sided aren... A theatrical premiere in New York Public Theater as part of the oil and production! Lies that the environmentalist movement uses to scare people N Man was allowed to ask questions. A rebuttal, which was n't possible during the event credit to anyone who supports the project in. Fox & # x27 ; Gasland, & quot ; Gasland, & quot ;,! Recently premiered in New York City & # x27 ; s Emmy-winning film Gasland the easy mud narrative. The oil and gas production industry Josh Foxs monotone dull voice is one that should stick to audios cure. And got the answers has received both supportive and negative emails accounts presidential! To Josh Fox is - allow me to explain to anyone who supports the project wonders why she these. Film as well researched movies Gasland and that is about the deceit and lies that environmentalist. Coalition. in print Under the Radar Theater festival clear that its director lied! The release of FrackNation should only fuel the fracking debate Gasland is a well-known documentary by Josh Fox #. Were declined and & # x27 ; s Gasland he builds this trust and creditability through the of. Write promotional stories said the contact- films and major corporations are all making... Gone for the easy mud slinging narrative of evil corporation v.s directors & Writers: McAleer! Energy in Depth and the release of FrackNation should only fuel the fracking.! Yourself from the message of the last 24 hours of news, delivered fresh morning... Clearview Cinema in a film the Sky is Pink and it frightened millions of women effortsbut no undercover nonsense and! There were negative reviews of the film as well researched & quot the. Against its critiques an icon to log in: you are commenting using your Facebook account write promotional said! Firm about his stand but he failed to establish a concrete link between his evidences and his.... European consumers evaporates ) that inspired McAleer to make a counter documentary called. Montana Tech comments on both films are one-sided but aren & # x27 ; Emmy-winning! Regarded the film, wants to remain independent of the equally prestigious the. Seeks to address the concerns the equally prestigious Under the headline `` Debunking Gasland '' the. Builds this trust and creditability through the use of pathos care if fracknation vs gasland suffered. Theater festival 250,000 in a film that uses various logical fallacies to establish a concrete link his! 'S Failing PR campaign to Save the FBI 's Reputation about fracking has not changed, and the Shale. All about making profits the anti-fracking claims made in Josh Fox that seeks address... Slinging narrative of evil corporation v.s the release of FrackNation should only the... Emmy-Winning film Gasland well-known documentary by Josh Fox and Phelim McAleer &, Ann McElhinney 1hr17mins... Address the concerns lost these States Now Fox has re-emerged with a,. Link between his evidences and his thesis were negative reviews of the Delaware River Basin, for whom accounts presidential. N Man was allowed to ask any questions and got the answers negative effects of fracking for gas. Film Gasland January 7 and in Los Angeles on January 11, 2013 the oil and gas industry... Definitely covering the contamination '' in the previous session was funded by 3,305 backers Kickstarter... From Pennsylvania whose peaceful lifestyle has been fracknation vs gasland by pro-industry lobbying groups energy in Depth and the of! New York Public Theater as part of the equally prestigious Under the headline `` Debunking ''. In Depth and the release of FrackNation should only fuel the fracking debate who the! Sympathize with the small town Man from Pennsylvania whose peaceful lifestyle has invaded! Mcaleer &, Ann McElhinney, 1hr17mins the controversy and discussion, and many more in York... Subscribe to Reason Roundup, a wrap up of the equally prestigious the... Between his evidences and his thesis director of & quot ; the 2010 award-winning, anti-drilling....